Before You Mediate a “Child Won’t Go” Case
A Pre-Mediation and Mediation Checklist for Counsel
Parent Child Contact Problem (PCCP) cases require more than the usual mediation preparation. This checklist is designed to help counsel identify the information, people, questions, and possible structures that may matter when a child is resisting or refusing contact.
Download the Checklist (Word) →Before Mediation
The Current Situation
☐ Child’s age(s).
☐ What does the current Parenting Plan or timesharing order require?
☐ What contact is actually occurring now?
☐ When did the resistance or refusal begin?
☐ Is the child refusing all contact, or particular overnights, transitions, activities, or circumstances?
☐ Has contact progressively decreased?
☐ What actually happens when it is time for the child to go?
Professional Involvement
☐ Individual therapist for the child.
☐ Parent therapist(s).
☐ Family counselor or family therapist.
☐ Reunification therapist.
☐ Parenting coordinator.
☐ Guardian ad litem.
☐ Psychological, custody, or other neutral evaluation.
☐ Other professional involved with the family.
☐ Are there written reports, evaluations, or recommendations the mediator should receive in advance?
What Has Already Been Tried?
☐ Informal schedule changes.
☐ Graduated contact.
☐ Therapeutic contact or reunification work.
☐ Neutral exchanges or transitions.
☐ Parenting coordination.
☐ Court intervention.
☐ Other efforts.
☐ What worked—even temporarily?
☐ What made things worse?
What Should the Mediator Know Before Everyone Arrives?
☐ Provide relevant orders and the current Parenting Plan.
☐ Provide relevant evaluations, reports, and recommendations.
☐ Identify significant pending motions or hearings.
☐ Alert the mediator that parent-child contact is a central issue.
☐ Identify professionals whose input may matter.
☐ Consider whether professional participation during some portion of mediation would be useful.
☐ Identify immediate issues that must be addressed even if the entire dispute cannot be resolved.
During Mediation: Questions Worth Exploring
Keep an Open Mind About the Source of the Resistance
☐ Are we too quickly assuming we know why the child is resisting contact?
☐ Could an objective, neutral evaluator help identify what is actually occurring?
☐ Are there concerns involving alcohol or drug use?
☐ Are discipline or parenting-style differences contributing to the problem?
☐ Has something changed in either household?
☐ What role, if any, are a stepparent, new partner, step-siblings, or half-siblings playing?
☐ What are teachers, school counselors, coaches, or other school personnel observing?
☐ Is the child’s behavior different at school or in other settings than it is with either parent?
What Kind of Professional Help Fits the Problem?
☐ Individual counseling for the child?
☐ Family counseling?
☐ Reunification therapy?
☐ Parenting coordination?
☐ Neutral psychological or other objective evaluation?
☐ Does the family need treatment—or does it first need better information about what is actually happening?
Think in Steps, Not Just Endpoints
If regular contact is not presently working, consider whether a graduated plan can create a path forward:
Texting → Phone Calls → Video Calls → Short Visits → Meals / Activities → Daytime Contact → Overnights → Weekends → Regular Timesharing
☐ Would the child be more comfortable knowing a trusted person is nearby—for example, in the building or immediately available?
☐ Could initial visits occur in a familiar or neutral setting?
☐ Should frequency increase before duration increases?
☐ What objective benchmarks would trigger the next step?
☐ Who will determine whether those benchmarks have been met?
☐ When will the parents review progress?
☐ What happens if the plan stalls or the child’s resistance increases?
Build a Plan That Can Actually Be Followed
☐ Define communication protocols between the parents.
☐ Identify each parent’s specific responsibilities.
☐ Set realistic timelines.
☐ Use measurable benchmarks where possible.
☐ Set review dates.
☐ Include contingency provisions if the plan is not working.
☐ Identify when additional professional involvement or court review may be appropriate.
The Goal Does Not Have to Be Agreement About Why
Parents may leave mediation still profoundly disagreeing about why their child is resisting contact. That does not necessarily prevent them from agreeing about what happens next.
Look for the next workable step—not necessarily the final solution.