Mediation Failed. Now What?

A Neutral Confidential Opinion May Help.

By Diana Tennis · 2026

The Hypo: The case has been pending for two years. Discovery is substantially complete. Both sides have capable lawyers and good experts. The parties have mediated—perhaps more than once. And they are still $750,000 apart.

One side is convinced its business valuation will carry the day. The other believes the methodology will not withstand scrutiny. Both clients have heard for months why their position is right. Trial is approaching, fees are mounting, and another mediation may simply mean paying everyone to have the same conversation again.

But what if both sides agreed on one person they trusted to answer the question neither side can answer for itself:

How is this dispute likely to look to an experienced family judge?

That is where a Neutral Confidential Opinion may help.

The First Question to Ask

A Neutral Confidential Opinion will not make sense in every case. The threshold questions may be surprisingly simple:

Will everyone give meaningful weight to the opinion of a neutral they know and trust?

If the answer is yes, the next question is whether obtaining that opinion is likely to be faster and more financially efficient than continuing to lumber toward trial.

That assessment should include the realities of the trial ahead. How well do you know the assigned judge? How much experience does that judge have with the issues involved? How much trial time will the case require, how much time will actually be given, and over what period? And how much more will the parties spend getting there? What are the odds of judicial error or inadequate findings? What appellate timetable and costs are reasonably likely?

A neutral opinion does not replace the right to take a case to trial. It gives the parties another piece of information with which to decide whether they really need to. Because settlement brings finality.

What Kinds of Impasse May Be Appropriate?

The valuation impasse. Two qualified experts reach dramatically different values for a closely held business, a variety of local and international real properties, the award-winning race horses, or the Fabergé eggs. The parties have spent heavily on discovery and expert fees, and neither side believes it has any reason to move.

The alimony impasse. The parties may agree about the meaning of the statute but disagree as to its impact on the alimony amount to be paid. Each side believes the statutory factors and evidence strongly favor its position.

The “everything is settled except…” case. After a long mediation, the parties resolve parenting, the house, retirement accounts, and most financial issues. One significant issue remains, and neither party is willing to jeopardize what has otherwise been accomplished by conceding it.

The battle of the experts. Both sides have retained qualified experts. The reports are complete, the opinions are far apart, and neither lawyer knows how the competing witnesses will actually fare under questioning. Rather than wait until trial to find out, the parties may want an experienced neutral to hear from the experts, ask questions, and assess not only the substance of their opinions but how those opinions may be received by a family judge.

The Process Can Fit the Problem

There is no reason every Neutral Confidential Opinion should look the same. The process can be designed around the question the parties actually need answered.

On the papers. The parties jointly identify the issues and submit agreed materials, expert reports, and written presentations. I review them and provide an oral or written assessment. This can include an opinion as to a reasonable range of settlement—and what the weaknesses of each side may be—more information than you are likely to receive at the most interactive case management conference.

A focused presentation. Counsel present argument and selected evidence on the disputed issue, creating something closer to a streamlined hearing without undertaking a full trial.

A hybrid approach. The documentary record may be submitted in advance, while selected witnesses—particularly competing experts—testify and are questioned. This can give both sides valuable information not only about the merits of the competing opinions, but about how those witnesses and opinions may actually be received.

I will work with the parties and their lawyers to design the process. The goal is not to recreate every expense and formality of trial. It is to provide the neutral with enough reliable information to give the parties the assessment they came for.

An Important Limitation

I will not provide a Neutral Confidential Opinion in a case in which I have served as the mediator. The two roles are fundamentally different. A mediator receives confidential communications from each side that cannot become the basis for a later neutral assessment of the merits. If I have mediated the case, another neutral should provide the opinion.

Confidentiality

Much like mediation, this is a confidential process. The parties accept what they jointly agree to and learn what there is to be learned…and whatever does not make its way into a written settlement agreement remains confidential and cannot be used for or against either party.

Why Ask for an Opinion at All?

Because uncertainty is expensive.

Lawyers spend enormous amounts of time assessing risk for their clients, but advocacy necessarily affects the conversation. A neutral who has spent years both presenting family cases and deciding them can provide a different perspective—not because that opinion predicts what a particular judge will do, but because it gives both sides the same independent assessment at the same time.

Sometimes that confirms that the parties really do need a trial. Sometimes it identifies a weakness, risk or possibility that changes the conversation. And sometimes it provides just enough movement to get a case that was almost settled across the finish line.

The Last Question to Ask Before Trial

Trial will sometimes be necessary. A Neutral Confidential Opinion is not intended to prevent that.

But before spending the additional time and dollars required to reach trial, there is a question worth asking:

If both sides would trust the judgment of the same experienced neutral, do they really need to wait for the judge to tell them?

A Neutral Confidential Opinion does not decide the case. It gives the parties another piece of information with which to decide the case themselves.